跳到主要內容

Chapter 4, p.19: Idilio Trunco


"Idilio Trunco"
"End of the Affair"
This is one of the greatest of the great Castillo valses. I remember some milongueros singing along with it at a party a few years ago, and Miguel Balbi, who sings tango in clubs, kept repeating the last line"No hay NADA entre nosotros... ANDATE por favor!"
They were trying to match the sharpness and emotion of Castillo's voice, and they kept shaking their heads and laughing at how difficult it was. The words are about a man who has absolutely reached his limit with a woman. He doesn't pull any punches, and his message is clear:  "I'm finished with you... understand? I'm sick of your games. You've hurt me for the last time, so... get out of here!!"
Ernesto Delgado and Miguelito kept marveling at the difficulty of staying with Castillo, and also chuckling at the half funny, half tragic lyrics. I mean, it is tragic—but then, most of us have been there—and we lived through it. So from the distance of a few years, it's possible to see a touch of humor in the way Castillo hammers out that last line:

IDILIO TRUNCO, Balcarce con Castillo 

Go away...
don’t come here begging;
bringing back memories
of our tragic affair.
The only thing you'll find here
are the ruins of a love
that was the happiest thing
I ever had.
Don't come back.
Your begging and your tears
aren't going to erase
the betrayal you left in my soul.
I can forgive the meanness
and the treachery inside you—
but don't ever forget, woman,
that I died for you.
Why have you come?
Can't you see that I'm sick
from all the suffering
caused by your love?
Can't you see my pain?
Everything is finished.
There's nothing between us...
so please... just get out of here!
Andate...
no vengas con tus súplicas
a recordar las horas
de aquel idilio trágico.
Que sólo has de encontrar aquí
las ruinas de un amor
que fue la dicha más feliz
que yo por vos acaricié.
No vuelvas.
Tus ruegos y tus lágrimas
no han de borrar de mi alma
tu acción que ha sido pérfida.
Te puedo perdonar el mal
que halle de tu traición en vos,
pero no olvidarás, mujer,
que he muerto para vos.
¿A qué has venido?
¿No ves que estoy enfermo
de tanto haber sufrido
por culpa de tu amor?
¿No ves se va mi pena?
Ya todo ha terminado.
No hay nada entre nosotros...
¡Andate, por favor!

"Andate" is a strong word in castellano. In Argentina, you would normally say, "Deberías irte"  ("You should go"). Andate is like saying, "Beat it!" or "Hit the road!"  It's something you might yell at a dog trespassing in your yard.
Like all the great tango singers, Castillo is also an actor. He begins relatively calmly, but as he tells his story, he begins to get worked up. The "Andate" at the beginning is noticeably different from the one at the end, as he moves from indignation, into something approaching rage. I really love the energy and passion in this vals. Castillo is a fantastic singer. We know a good milonguero (Gerardo Quiroz) who will only dance to valses if they're sung by Castillo.
After watching Miguel and Ernesto, I've tried to sing along with Castillo and Echagüe to some of the fast tangos. I'm neither a singer, nor a native speaker, so it's just for fun—but it's still an interesting exercise. If you try it, you'll get some idea of how difficult it is to sing tango. I'm not able to make may mouth move fast enough to keep up with the music, and Castillo's cadences are very complicated. I still can't figure out how he manages to squeeze in all the words at the end of this vals and still finish with the orchestra.
For me, great valses like this one are at the very pinnacle of tango dancing. Listen to the totality of the music, and the way Castillo's voice soars and plays around the cadence. This one has about 80 strong beats per minute, with two weak beats squeezed in between. It's super fast, but it’s not staccato (it doesn’t have a lot of sharp, distinct notes). Like most of the best valses, the cadence is fast and clear, but everything still flows forward smoothly... so there’s really only one way to express it: Your body needs to keep moving and turning, while your feet express the compás by hitting some of the very fast weak beats.
We'll discuss this a lot more and give examples in Chapters 5 & 6, but for now, the thing to remember is that the “park and perform” tango they sell in workshops has nothing to do with this music. This vals is a round hole—and stunts like volcadas and sacadas are square pegs. They won't fit.

留言

這個網誌中的熱門文章

Chapter 5, p.3: 有力度落差的身體語言:Blas

Blas 三年前,Blas 和 Graciela 決定在市中心創辦一個新的 milonga。 照布宜諾斯艾利斯的傳統,主辦者會以跳一支 La Cumparsita 開場。 這不算正式表演, 但其他舞者會禮貌地退到場邊, 在最後給新人一點掌聲—— 象徵帶來好運。 看起來這場「開場舞」真的帶來好運, 因為之後這個 milonga 就變得非常受歡迎。 但如果你看到它的第一晚, 可能完全想不到會有今天這樣的盛況。 那天, 我想只有 Alej 和我, 再加上一團剛表演完、正在收拾樂器的樂隊, 差不多就這麼多人。 以下就是當天, Blas 和 Graciela 跳的 D'Arienzo 版本的 La Cumparsita : 比較這支影片與前一頁的那支 把這支影片與上一頁的影片放在一起看,你會立刻發現許多不同。 Blas 的移動比 Ismael 多,也做了更多「步子」(我永遠搞不清楚該怎麼稱呼探戈裡的那些動作——它們是步?套路?還是組合?) 如果硬要說, 你也許會覺得這支影片裡的 Blas 跳得比 Ismael 更「複雜」。 但真的是嗎? 如果是,那為什麼? 因為音樂不同? 場合不同? 還是因為 Blas 本來就喜歡加入更多元素,而 Ismael 選擇極簡? 我認為——三者都有一點。 音樂確實不同 我原本想說《La Cumparsita》比《Extraña》更複雜, 但後來發現事情沒那麼簡單。 《Extraña》屬於 Laurenz 的後期風格, 源自 De Caro 的「新派、精緻、音樂性強」的演進; 而 Blas 跳的是最古老的探戈之一, 由「節奏之王」D'Arienzo 所演奏—— 而 D'Arienzo 反而常被嫌「太簡單」。 所以,你若說 Blas 的音樂比較複雜, 其實會陷入矛盾。 但 D'Arienzo 的《La Cumparsita》 確實比《Extraña》有更多段落、更多轉折。 而且,《Extraña》的旋律線條比較平滑( conjunctive ), 上上下下都像在滑行; 但《Cumparsita》的音階跳動較大( disjunctive ), 高音和低音之間的落差明顯。 這對跳舞有什麼影響? 音樂越有段落、越有力度差、越「跳躍」, ...

Chapter 5, p.18, Ricardo 留給我們的事物 Ricardo Vidort (5)

  Ricardo 留給我們的事物 (What Ricardo Left Us) 我一向對那些只在意華麗舞步與炫技動作的人缺乏耐性。 但或許我也不該那麼嚴厲—— 因為我自己也曾經走過那條路。 我很早就意識到,1990 年代在美國被包裝販售的「舞台探戈」其實毫無意義; 然而,要真正理解 真正的探戈 ,我仍花了很長的時間。 我和 Natu 五年前那場辯論,就是最好的例子。 那時,我雖然常去 milonga、與 milongueros 相處, 卻還沒有培養出一雙真正懂得「看探戈」的眼睛。 在我當時的眼裡, Tete 那種充滿動能、肢體誇張的舞看起來「更厲害」。 如今回頭看,那真是個錯誤的比較。 Tete 當然是個偉大的舞者(我們稍後會談他), 但拿他與 Ricardo 相比, 就像把蘋果和橘子放在一起比。 現在,經過大約 一萬支舞的經驗 之後, 我終於理解了當年 Natu 想告訴我的事: Ricardo Vidort 的確是探戈的「大建築師」(Grand Architect of Tango Dancing)。 我不打算在這裡進行艱深的技術分析, 但如果你想從 Ricardo 身上學些什麼, 我可以給你一些觀察的方向。 首先、也是最明顯的一點—— 他 永遠在節拍(compás)裡。 他曾告訴我, 以前他和其他 milongueros 之間有個遊戲: 誰在一整晚的舞裡 第一個踩出節拍外的步子 , 那個人就得請大家喝香檳。 他笑著說:「我從來沒請過。」 我相信這是真的。 我完全無法想像他會有哪一步走在音樂之外。 Ricardo 有一種極其獨特的方式, 能把節奏感**融入 giro(旋轉)與 corridita(短跑步)**裡。 有時他只踩重拍, 有時又在 giro 裡穿插一連串快速的步伐, 進出之間連綴成節奏的波浪。 他會向前或向後做 corrida,中途加入停頓, 甚至讓步伐畫出弧線。 他還將 sacada(穿插步) 與 vai-ven(搖擺步 / rock step) 靈巧地編入 corrida 中, 這是別人做不到的。 他有一種特別的動作方式—— 一隻腳穩穩踩地, 另一隻腳則像刀尖般快速「刺」出細小的節奏, 同時仍保持著領舞的控制。 探戈通常是以 步與重心轉換 為基礎, 但 Ricardo ...

Chapter 5, p.13: 探戈的樂趣 The Joy of Tango

The Joy of Tango  探戈的樂趣 你可能會注意到,Alej 和 Alito 在裡面犯了好幾個明顯的錯誤。 但我能說什麼呢?探戈的本質就是享受樂趣, 而他們兩個跳得那麼開心,我根本無法捨棄這段。 即使他們彼此絆到、踩錯拍子,看起來都忍不住想笑。 再說,那音樂! 如果聽了不會讓你想立刻站起來跳舞, 那你可能該去找另一個興趣了。 這是 2004 年秋天的一個下午, Alito 和 Alejandra 在 Lo de Celia’s 隨著 Biaggi 的音樂, 輕盈地在舞池中滑動。 作業說明: 請運用你受過訓練的眼光,觀察並指出 Alito 如何以不同的方式「玩音樂」。 你能描述他如何用一種方式表現 節奏(compás) ,又以另一種方式表現 旋律(melody) 嗎? 同時,請討論在探戈中「保持放鬆與身體中心穩定」的重要性。 原文: This always happens. I start out with a great plan, but then I come across a different piece of film and get sidetracked. I was going to use a short clip of  Alito  dancing with another  milonguera  to demonstrate something or other—but then I found this one, and I had to use it instead. I realize it’s too long, it doesn’t show what I wanted… and you’ll probably notice that  Alej  and Alito make several obvious mistakes. But what can I say? Tango's about having fun, and Alej and Alito seem to be enjoying themselves so much that I couldn’t leave it out. Even whe...